Other Alternative Explanations

Scripture: They answered, “John the Baptist; others, Elijah; still others, that one of the ancient prophets has come back.” “But you,” He asked them, “who do you say that I am?” Peter answered, “God’s Messiah!” Luke 9:19-20

Observation: Before Peter declares Jesus the Messiah, the question of what other are saying is asked and answered. The explanations proffered are nonsensical. The idea that Jesus would be John the Baptist - who was just beheaded months before and whom many people had seen - makes no sense. The offer of Elijah makes sense from a Jewish perspective regarding prophesy of the return of Elijah, but there is no such possible alignment between Jesus and Elijah other than both being great. As for any other prophet, there is no expectation that any of the prophets would return.

The most logical explanation - that Jesus is himself a new prophet - isn't part of the scenario. This is because even the average people still seeking truth can tell Jesus is greater than a mere 'average prophet'. There is something great occurring, and the people know it. Yet they are willing to attribute the unprecedented concept of a resurrected ancient prophet to this greatness instead of the one concept they have been anticipating for hundreds of years ... the coming of Messiah.

Application: This is the nature of mankind's relationship with God ... that we are willing to make up wild guesses to explain him instead of listening to and believing his explanation. God said he was sending the Messiah. God never said he was bringing back any random prophets. Yet people make up the latter and ignore the former.

Today, God says he will care for his sheep, help us through all hard times, and work for the good for those who love him. Yet I rarely put my full trust in him. I take on struggles without prayer for help, and I worry about life without seeking comfort. I make up a narrative for taking care of myself and my family and my community and my city and my country and my planet, and I don't ask God what his plans for all these are so I can simply join him there.

I need to follow God's narrative, not my alternatives. I wish to walk in his will and by his chosen path, not wander lost and declaring I know the way.

Prayer: Lord, this day may I give my concerns to you. I am worried about our cash flow, and though I know we have plenty I desire to provide for children straining to find their way. I want to make all paths available to them. However, I know you have already chosen their path, and you have provided plenty for it. May I lean into your will, surrender to your guidance, and find comfort in your arms. Amen.